Lahore (HRNW) – The Lahore High Court has acquitted a man who had previously been sentenced to 25 years’ imprisonment in a rape case, while also laying down significant legal principles governing the prosecution of rape and sexual offence cases.
In a detailed judgment, Justice Amjad Rafiq ruled that where an accused is charged under the legal provisions relating to rape, the prosecution must prove the offence of rape beyond reasonable doubt to secure a conviction.
The court observed that a conviction for rape cannot be sustained merely by concluding that sexual relations took place if the prosecution fails to establish the legal ingredients of rape.
“It cannot be held that if rape is not proved, the accused should still be punished for rape on the basis that sexual intercourse occurred,” the judgment emphasized.
Justice Amjad Rafiq further ruled that if the offence of rape is not proven, the accused cannot subsequently be convicted for another sexual offence unless such an offence was specifically charged and established in accordance with the law.
The court also clarified that a rape case cannot be converted into a case of illicit sexual relations simply to uphold a conviction after the principal charge of rape fails.
Legal experts believe the ruling reinforces the principle of fair trial and due process by emphasizing that criminal convictions must be based strictly on the specific charges framed and the evidence presented before the court.
The judgment is expected to serve as an important judicial precedent for future cases involving allegations of rape and other sexual offences in Pakistan.
Important Note
This report is based on the Lahore High Court’s reported judgment. The decision reflects the court’s legal interpretation of the applicable law and may be subject to further legal proceedings or appeal where permitted by law.
Support HRNW
Support independent human rights and public interest journalism:
https://www.hrnww.com/?page_id=1083
